This trophy is awarded for completing all of the Butcher challenges. In total there are three challenges (listed below - this cannot be completed until Inferno mode)
Location: Act 1 - The Imprisoned Angel - Chamber of Suffering
Challenge #1 - Don't Stand in the Fire
Kill the Butcher without being Burned by floor fires or being grabbed by ancient spear in Hell mode or higher.
This one is about your awareness. The floor panels will light up before they start to burn you so make sure you move out of the way the second they light up. The Butcher will occasionally use his ancient spear ability. Before he does this he will point at your character which is your cue to move to the side!
Challenge #2 - A Brief Butchering
Kill the Butcher in under 2 minutes in Inferno Mode
The easiest way to complete this is to put the difficulty on easy and have a character with decent gear. Just attack him with all you have and he should fall well below the 2 minute mark
Challenge #3 - Stunning Reversal
Kill the Butcher while he is stunned by his own charge attack in Nightmare mode or higher
Occasionally the Butcher will charge your character, this will be started by a large fire line appearing. Move out of the way of this and the Butcher will be stunned for a couple of seconds. All you have to do for this challenge is lower his health until he has hardly any left and then wait until he charges you. When he is stunned finish him off and the challenge will be completed.
If you have any suggestions to make this guide better, please PM me or post a comment here