There is a very simple way of getting this trophy is you don't mind changing the settings in your favor: removing offsides.
Yes, going into My Madden and then to the plethora of settings you can remove a penalty called "offside," a rule that keeps players on their respective side of the field. With this off, you can position your favorite defensive end right in front of/near the quarertback. Using a defensive lineman (one of the players at the line of scrimmage) may get you the following trophy as well:
Of course, there are more settings you can play with to make all of the trophies easier but, for this trophy, the biggest change is allowing offsides. The CPU won't use it but you are certainly able to.
Do this ten times, maybe even scoring a fumble recovery for a TD, and you're up one silver trophy.
Let me know if I can improve on this solution and, as always, happy hunting!