You can get this trophy at any time, it can even be the first trophy you earn!
In the House of Bad go downstairs and go left as far as you can, so you are in Strong Bad's room. (The room with a green floor, yellow walls and posters.) On the floor of this room is the "Fun Machine", click on it by pressing X, then press X again to start. Now you just need to concentrate on getting 2000 points in one game of Math Kickers featuring the AlgeBros. It's not too difficult as you get 6 lives, but it may take you a few practice tries first.
Travel right until the ninjas attack you, then just spam O while moving up or down to dodge the ninja stars they throw at you. You won't have to dodge much as they seem to just throw the ninja stars in random directions, just pay attention and you'll be fine. At the end of each level you will have a boss fight. The "boss" will be a giant box with equations in it and it is very easy to defeat as it only has one attack, which is a simple slam attack. The boss will always stay at the top of the screen, when it starts to float just move to the bottom of the screen until it slams down and then go back up and attack it by mashing X or O when your characters are standing next to it. You will need to get to the fourth boss to have enough points for this trophy.
When you have 2000+ points, just let yourself die then press Start to quit Math Kickers featuring the AlgeBros. The trophy will unlock after you quit the game.
Please vote positively if this guide was helpful and feel free to leave a comment if I can improve it in any way.