Very easy trophy. Start up a quick play game on Rookie difficulty. You will want to be the New Orleans Saints so you can utilize the great Drew Brees and his incredible accuracy. You can play against any team you wish.
You need a minimum of 20 pass attempts. I suggest you stick to short(er) pass plays. Throwing all-out bombs will most likely end in more incompletions than you'd like. The tight end has great hands and so does the receiver Marques Colston. If you through for exactly 20 passes, you must have completed 19 of them to get this. So if you are at 18/20, you will need to complete 5 more passes with no incompletions, which would bring you to 23/25. If you are at around 15/20, you might as well start the game again.
This trophy pops at the end of the game.