-( This trophy can be overlooked, so be careful. )-
Act IV (Showdown): In the confrontation with Conroy, make sure you've got the laser set up to aim back at the Wind Fountain but keep the depetrifying eyes within yours. When you sent Peck out after the fish, it will hit Conroy and momentarily surprise him before he shoots you and restarts the process. This can only be done in this segment so do this before you solve the puzzle.