This is story based and can’t be missed. You have to get out of the subway station first.
*** Spoiler - click to reveal ***The trophy pops as soon as you see Dana the 3rd time after answering the 2nd phone and walking through the various alley ways after her while working your way down toward the city.
. Be sure to look all around subway station and alleys for the notes and vox pops required by storied-trophy. There are 7 notes and 5 voxpops. You can’t go back up the hill after this trophy (although guide says you can use level select later).