As of 31st of December 2017, this trophy is no longer obtainable.
Original posted solution for when it did work:
After finishing the fifth game and watching a cutscene, you will start a cutscene in which the draft pick starts, but the game will stop and ask you to pre-order to continue. At this point I dismissed the pre-order and was then given the option to play a bonus game called "...IN A BIG POND".
Playing this game will unlock the trophy.