Shay Act 2
This trophy is missable. During Act 2, Shay will need to rescue Brother Lightbeard from his cloud. After doing so, return to Meriloft and head down into the Meriloft Maidens Feast Area. Brother Lightbeard is trapped here in a cage. Talk to him three times to get the dialogue that references the name of this trophy. Once you have heard that dialogue, the trophy will pop.