| Name | Description | |
| Tour De (Sail) Forth | Earn all the other trophies. |  |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. |  |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. |  |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Tootorial | Finish the Tutorial. | |
| In Service Of Glory And Valor | Receive all of the Croaker Medals from Admiral Picklepea. | |
| Enter The Croakers | Have a chat with Agent Croquet in the Autumn Isles. | |
| Fish And Tips | Get a helpful Fish Tip from ol' Anglerwranglest Kerblapp. | |
| Blowfish Me Down | Win a game of Blowfish with Kerblapp and Othoo. | |
| Crushed Ice | Knock over an Ice Spire onto an enemy vessel. | |
| Pengy Fun | Startle a pengy into jumping into the water for a swim. | |
| Over The Moon | Recieve all of the Royal Moonflowers from Majesty Nausicaa. | |
| Fish Kabob | Harpoon a Tainted Barnacle from a Sea Creature. | |
| This Magik Moment | The Magik Shell Shop is open for business. | |
| Don't I Know You? | Visit Captain Toot and Goose in the Postgame. | |
| Sail Forth! | Finish the game and sail off into the sunset. |  |
| Baby's First Thingamabob | Convey a strange Ancient Junk relic to a Lightkeeper. | |
| Whosits And Whatsits Galore | Deliver every piece of Ancient Junk to the Lightkeepers. | |
| Hook, Line and Stinker | Catch every fish and complete your collection. | |
| Shooting Star | Photograph everything for Snapps and complete your collection. | |
| Getting Hooked | Fill out half of your Fish Collection. Keep it up! | |
| Snapping Turtle | Fill your Photo Collection halfway. Nice work! | |
| Gateway Slug | Spend a modest amount of Boat Parts at Shipshape Shops. | |
| I Don't Like The Slugs | Spend an abnormal amount of Boat Parts at the Shipshape Shops. | |
| But The Slugs Like Me | Spend a preposterous amount of Boat Parts at the Shipshape Shops. | |
| This Is Fine | What's that smell? Is something burning? | |
| Great Balls Of Fire | Light an enemy vessel on fire. | |
| Race In Yo Face | Win a race against Zimothy and Dexter. | |
| Built For Speed | Defeat the Deep Six at least once in every World. | |
| Nice Shootin' Duds | Complete one of Wesley Dudshooter's target courses. | |
| Crackshot | Complete all of Wesley Dudshooter's target courses. | |
| Light Up the Night | Complete your first Light Prism event with the Lightkeepers. | |
| Lights Out | Complete all of the Lighthouse Prism events. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Crovert Ops | Track down an illegal trader for the Croakers. | |
| Croaker Command's Most Wanted | Completely shut down the illegal trade ring for the Croakers. | |
| Sweeter Than Honey | Conclude the sticky situation between Marley and Scampy. | |
| Wind Master | Keep your sails perfectly adjusted for at least 15 seconds. | |
| Boarding Party | Successfully board an enemy vessel. | |
| Davy Jones | Sink your first enemy vessel. | |
| Tekk Savvy | Capture a Tekk Clan Tanker. | |