| Name | Description | |
| King of the Diamond! | Achieve all trophies in MLB® The Show™ 22. |  |
| Four-bagger Express! | In any stadium, hit an inside the park home run. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams |  |
| Big Fly Ohtani San! | Hit a home run with any starting pitcher. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Locked In! | Achieve a hit while using PCI Anchor. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Pitching Rook! | Promote to Rookie pitching difficulty in Dynamic Difficulty. | |
| Batting Rook! | Promote to Rookie batting difficulty in Dynamic Difficulty. | |
| Professional Framer! | Throw more than 60% first-pitch strikes in a complete-game victory. Must be done in a full, uninterrupted, 9 inning game. The trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, by switching teams, by simulating, and excludes DD moments) |  |
| Flashing the Leather! | Turn two double plays within a complete game. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Just a bit outside... | While pitching, strike out a batter with a pitch outside the zone. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Sombrero Dealer! | Strikeout the same batter three times within a game. Must be done in a full, uninterrupted, 9 inning game. The trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, by switching teams, by simulating, and excludes DD moments | |
| Did we just become friends? | Enter into any co-op game. Enter a co-op exhibition game with a friend or random player | |
| Base Collector! | Collect three stolen bases within a complete game. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Big Fly! | Achieve a perfect-perfect hit for a home run. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Backwards K! | Trigger a perfect pinpoint accuracy pitch that strikes out a batter looking. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Minor Batting Adjustments! | Promote to Minors Batting difficulty in Dynamic Difficulty. | |
| Minor Pitching Adjustments! | Promote to Minors Pitching difficulty in Dynamic Difficulty. | |
| Fight Fire With Fire! | Hit a home run off a pitch going 100 mph or more. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams |  |
| The Portal is Open! | Create a Diamond Dynasty team. | |
| Don’t rub it! | As a batter, get on base by a hit by pitch (HBP). This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Ugly Finder! | As a batter, record an out on a perfect-perfect hit. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Bring in the Closer! | In any mode, earn a save with your closer to win the game. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Ribbie! | With a runner on base, achieve a perfect-perfect hit and score a run. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Coming in Hot! | As a fielder, catch a 110 mph or harder hit baseball for an out. This trophy is not awarded if completed in a local multiplayer game, practice mode, or by switching teams | |
| Pitching Dabbler! | Promote to Amateur pitching difficulty in Dynamic Difficulty. | |
| Bat Dabbler! | Promote to Amateur batting difficulty in Dynamic Difficulty. | |