| Name | Description | |
| Final Cut | Earn all trophies |  |
| Body of Work | Bring all the movie posters to your cabin |  |
| Debut | Find your first movie poster |  |
| A Beautiful Mind | Complete the clock puzzle without a single mistake | |
| Go Off Script | Ignore direction during the first key scene | |
| Hit Your Mark | Follow direction during the first key scene | |
| Show Restraint | Ignore direction during the second key scene | |
| Trust Your Instincts | Follow direction during the second key scene | |
| Let Go of Your Fear | Follow her direction during the third key scene | |
| Find Your Inner Voice | Follow his direction during the third key scene | |
| Go Against the Grain | Ignore direction during the fourth key scene | |
| Go With the Flow | Follow direction during the fourth key scene | |
| Closed Casket | Seal the Formless Man in a coffin | |
| We Are Not Alone | Bring all the mysterious items to your cabin | |
| You Can't Handle the Truth | Decrypt a mysterious item |  |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| A Slice of Life | Find your first photo slide | |
| Full Scoop | Listen to all the phonograph interviews | |
| Sound Bite | Use the phonograph | |
| In One Take | Get through the set without getting caught in the lights | |
| Lights, Camera, Action! | Begin shooting your movie | |
| The Perfect Storm | Send out an SOS | |
| Repair, Restore, Rebuild | Rebuild what was once broken. At least try. | |
| Rocket Science | Journey through space without hitting a single obstacle | |
| Se7en Seas | Save all the lost souls | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |
| Fisher King | Spot everything through the spyglass | |
| Fisherman | Spot something through the spyglass | |
| A Mosaic of Misery | View all the photo slides in your cabin | |
| Choice and Concequence | Take your first look behind the mysterious door | |
| Hidden Trophy | Continue playing to unlock this trophy. | |