Here is the full list of all 12 Welcome to James' story in the World of Our Church and Halloween (EU) trophies - there are 11 gold and 1 platinum.
Awarded after earning all other trophies
Complete Level 9
Complete Level 8
Complete Level 6
Complete Level 7
Complete Level 5
Complete Level 4
Meet Erin
Complete Level 3
Complete Level 2
Meet James
Complete Level 1