- A winning combination!
Use a wake-up taunt, land a Finisher, and immediately pin your opponent. (Single play)
- Excellent execution
Attack every body part at least once using the limb targeting system. (Single play/Exhibition)
- Reached the ropes!
Crawl to the ropes during a submission. (Single play)
- Redbox Big Moment
Break the announce table with an OMG! Moment. (Single play/Exhibition)
- This is my yard!
Create and play a match in at least one custom Arena. (Single play)
- We have a winner!
Win at least 20 matches on Hard difficulty or higher in Universe or Exhibition. (Single play)
- Over the ropes you go!
Eliminate 12 opponents with the same Superstar in a single Royal Rumble match. (Single play)
- Feed me more!
Win at least 50 matches on Hard difficulty or higher in Universe or Exhibition. (Single play)
- Match maker
Win in 20 match variations. (Single play)
- Everybody wins!
Win with 50 different Superstars. (Single play)
- NXT Takeover
Defeat John Cena using one of the NXT Superstars.
- The Giant killer
Beat Big Show using Rey Mysterio on Hard difficulty. (Single play)
- Unknown veteran
Win 10 times using a custom Superstar.
- Tap! Tap! Tap!
Make an opponent tap out with a submission that is not a Finisher or Signature move. (Single Play)
- Next Generation
Who Got NXT - Complete all objectives.
- Foundation of the future
Who Got NXT - Receive a grade of A or better in Proving Ground.
- Now that was a match!
Earn 3000 points or more playing ranked matches.
- A winner is you
Win 50 ranked matches.
- A fresh beginning
Play in an Online match (Player match/Ranked match).
- Mid-carder
Reach mid-carder rank playing ranked matches.
- One of a kind Superstar
Create a custom Superstar that uses a Superstar head.
- A creator is born
Upload some kind of user created content once.
- True Champion
2K Showcase - Complete "Hustle, Loyalty, Disrespect".
- The Kliq
2K Showcase - Complete "Best Friends, Bitter Enemies".
- Wrestling heritage
2K Showcase - Complete all objectives.
- The beginning of a record
2K Showcase - Complete "Hustle, Loyalty, Disrespect", 11/20/11 Survivor Series on Hard or higher.
- The Second City Savior
2K Showcase - Complete "Hustle, Loyalty, Disrespect", 7/17/11 Money In The Bank on Hard or higher.
- Frenemies
2K Showcase - Complete "Best Friends, Bitter Enemies", 8/25/02 SummerSlam on Hard or higher.
- Wrestling master
2K Showcase - Complete 50% of the objectives.
- Best in the World!
2K Showcase - Beat "Hustle, Loyalty, Disrespect" on Legend difficulty.
- Game over
2K Showcase - Beat "Best Friends, Bitter Enemies" on Legend difficulty.