Here is the full list of all 37 Madden NFL 16 trophies - there are 25 bronze, 6 silver, 5 gold and 1 platinum.
Congratulations on earning every Madden NFL 16 trophy!
Make it to a MUT Seasons Super Bowl.
Earn a first round bye in Ultimate Team Seasons.
Make the playoffs in Ultimate Team Seasons.
Successfully use the strip ball mechanic. (No SuperSim or Practice Mode)
Earn at least one bronze medal in all drills inside of Skills Trainer.
Defeat the Level 25 Boss of the Skills Trainer Gauntlet.
Draft a team with an OVR greater than 82 in Draft Champions.
Complete 5 Draft Events.
Make a user-pick with J.J. Watt. (No SuperSim or Practice Mode)
Record 4 assisted tackles in one game. (No SuperSim or Practice Mode)
Win a MUT auction.
Complete a MUT set.
Win a MUT Solo Challenge.
Earn at least a bronze medal in all 6 Run Concepts inside of Skills Trainer.
Complete a Draft Champions event undefeated.
Create a MUT Team.
Comeback and win when trailing by 17+ points at halftime. (No SuperSim or Co-Op)
Get hit with a neutral zone infraction penalty. (No SuperSim or Practice Mode)
Change 1 or more penalty sliders in the settings menu.
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 15,450
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 20,000
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 9,500
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 3,600
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 6,500
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 1,500
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 800
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 300
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 125
Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 25
Complete your first Draft Champions event.
Complete a Single-Player Draft Champions event.
Throw a Touchdown using the Touch Pass. (No SuperSim or Practice Mode)
Build a Team style (5 players of a particular team style).
Draft a player with an OVR at least 10 points higher than the base team's OVR in Draft Champions.
Explore Draft Champions mode.
Earn gold from a drill inside the Skills Trainer.