Here is the full list of all 25 Madden NFL 11 trophies - there are 8 bronze, 10 silver, 6 gold and 1 platinum.
Congratulations on earning every Madden NFL 11 trophy!
Return 2 kicks for touchdowns in one game with one player (no OTP)
Intercept 5 passes in a game (no OTP)
Win a Fight for the Fumble in the end zone for a TD (no OTP)
Catch 21 passes in a game with one player (no OTP)
Have a 92% or higher completion percentage in a game (min. 20 attempts, no OTP)
Win a game by at least 59 points (max qtr. len. 7 min, no OTP)
Have a perfect passer rating in a game (no OTP)
Have over 100 YAC in one game (no OTP)
Force 3 fumbles in a game (no OTP)
Stay in the pocket for 10 seconds (no OTP)
Break an 80+ yard touchdown run (no OTP)
Play the Pro Bowl (Franchise Mode)
Create a Game Plan
Rush for over 200 yards in a game with one player (no OTP)
Hold your opponent to under 100 yards of offense (min qtr. len. 5 min, no OTP)
Break 5 tackles in a game with one player (no OTP)
Record 5 sacks in a game with one player (no OTP)
Rush for 50 yards after the first hit in one game (no OTP)
Tackle the QB before he can hand the ball off (no OTP)
Kick a 60+ yard Field Goal (no OTP)
Return a punt for a touchdown (no OTP)
Complete the "Super Bowl Sunday" Madden Moment
Win after being behind in the last 2 min of the game (min qtr. len. 3 min, no OTP)
Intercept a pass and return it for a touchdown (no OTP)