Here is the full list of all 50 5 Star Wrestling trophies - there are 36 bronze, 11 silver, 2 gold and 1 platinum.
Earn all Trophies
Complete every Objective in Challenge Mode in 5 Star Wrestling
Complete every Challenge in the Mike Iceberg Tier
Complete ALL Survival Objectives in Challenge Mode
Complete ALL Comeback Objectives in Challenge Mode
Complete ALL Supercharged Objectives Challenge Mode
Complete ALL Seek & Destroy Objectives in Challenge Mode
Complete every Challenge in the Ragnabrök Tier
Complete ALL Time Objectives in Challenge Mode
Complete every Challenge in the Gregg Hearty Tier
Complete every Challenge in the HarVee Dee Tier
Complete every Challenge in the Curtis Angel Tier
Complete every Challenge in the Dynamite Pegasus Tier
Complete every Challenge in the Jonny Miavia Tier
Complete every Challenge in the Andy Organ Tier
Complete every Challenge in the 2 out of 3 Falls Tier
Complete every Challenge in the Falls Count Anywhere Tier
Win a 2 out of 3 Falls Match without conceding a fall
Unlock an in-game feature in the 5 Star Wrestling Shop
Earn 1,000,000 Coins
Complete every Challenge in the First Blood Tier
Complete every Challenge in the Last Man Standing Tier
Complete every Challenge in the Pinfall Only Tier
Complete every Challenge in the No Holds Barred Tier
Complete every Challenge in the Submission Tier
Receive a 5 Star Rating in a Player vs Player match
Complete every Challenge in the Wrestling Tier
Win a Main Event Challenge match
Get a 5 Star Rating and win in a Challenge Match
Perform an Illegal move as any Heel wrestler
Win a Challenge Match
Perform every one of Icebergs Finishers
Perform a Finisher Reversal
Playing as Curtis Angel, defeat Dynamite Pegasus and don't allow him to use his Finisher
Playing as Andy Organ, defeat Jonny Miavia and don't allow him to use his Finisher
Receive a 5 Star Rating for a match between two Rivals
Win an Exhibition Match with your head in red level damage
Perform any Corner Finishing move
Trigger a Move Fail by working your opponents legs until he can't execute lift up moves anymore
Perform a Tired Finishing move
Perform a Strong Finishing move
Open the Help Menu
Defeat a Brute as a Risk Taker
Successfully perform a Top Rope move with a Risk Taker
Win an Exhibition Match
Perform a Reversal
Perform back-to-back Quick Finishing moves
Perform a Wake-up Taunt followed by a Finisher
Perform both Taunts available to your wrestler in one match
Successfully perform any Finisher